Ideas for Learners Promoting Literacy, Inquiry, and Meaningful Learning Experiences
Ungifted by Gordon Korman
 

Book Summary

Donovan's prank has finally gone too far. He sits in the principal's office, worried that his fate might actually be expulsion, and a clerical error sends him to a school for advanced learners instead. Donovan's unimpressive academic performance at his new school is attributed to an environment that doesn't stimulate him appropriately, so his teachers continue to work to motivate him. His classmates continue to be puzzled by him. When he joins a robotics competition team, Donovan realizes he may have something genuine to contribute.
 
Ungifted book cover
Ungifted

Book Review

I have a couple of reservations about this book which stem from my bias as a gifted education specialist. One of the key messages in the book is that everyone has a talent to bring to a task - and I am an ardent supporter of that idea. I shudder at the implication that none of the kids at the advanced learning school are shown to have healthy social skills - and this is an unfortunate stereotype. In my experience, there are gifted students who struggle with social relationships, and there are gifted students who excel at personal interactions. The book seems to make fun of people who value gifted education in the first place, and while there are legitimate discussions and issues about that topic, until we can offer more flexibility and appropriate learning experiences for all students in our schools, I think it's an academic need, not a silly indulgence, as this book seems to imply. It's fair to argue that people sometimes take themselves too seriously, and we need Donovans in our world to remind us that a lighter approach is sometimes more effective. This is an entertaining story with a page-turning set of challenges for the protagonist. His predicament of hiding in plain sight is humorous, and as he begins to care and exert some genuine effort in school, Donovan becomes a character you can root for - beyond a Ferris Bueller sort of amusement that's established early on. This book is popular with many independent readers.

Topics and Themes for this book:

 
  • Troublemakers in School
  • Deception
  • Authority & Rebellion
 
  • Defining Yourself
  • Teamwork
  •  

Discussion Questions for this book:

The best discussion questions, of course, are generated by and contemplated by readers. These questions are designed to avoid major spoilers about the book, and to provide a starting point for teachers, parents, and student reading groups.


**Questions coming soon**

If you liked this book, you might also like . . .

 
Warp Speed book cover
Warp Speed
 
Zen and the Art of Faking It book cover
Zen and the Art of Faking It
 
Athlete vs. Mathlete book cover
Athlete vs. Mathlete